Claw machine games on phones: simulated games vs real-prize apps
A claw game on a phone can be a cartoon you play for fun, a game that sells random virtual items, or a remote control for a real machine in an arcade. They look alike in a store listing, but the rules, the costs and the risks differ. This guide sorts them out.
The three kinds
| Kind | What decides a win | What you can win | Main store rule |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1. Simulated, virtual prizes only | The game's code | Items inside the game | General game rules |
| 2. Simulated, with paid random items | The game's code | Random virtual items bought with money | Odds must be shown before purchase |
| 3. Real machine, played remotely | The physical claw and its settings | Physical prizes, shipped | Google Play: online crane game declaration |
Kind 1: simulated games with virtual prizes
These are ordinary games. A program draws the claw and decides whether it holds. Prizes stay inside the game and have no cash value. The main costs are your time, any ads you watch, and optional purchases such as extra plays. Our guide to what "free" means in claw games covers those costs.
Kind 2: simulated games that sell random items
Some claw games sell plays or capsules that give a random virtual item. That is the same mechanism as a loot box. Both app stores have rules for it:
- Apple's App Store Review Guidelines, section 3.1.1: apps offering "loot boxes" or other mechanisms that provide randomized virtual items for purchase "must disclose the odds of receiving each type of item to customers prior to purchase."
- Google Play's Payments policy: apps offering randomized virtual items from a purchase must clearly disclose the odds of receiving those items in advance of purchase.
So in an app from either store, you should find the odds before you pay for a random item. If you cannot find them, treat that as a warning sign.
Research has linked this kind of spending to problem gambling. In a 2018 survey of 7,422 gamers published in PLOS ONE, Zendle and Cairns found a link between the amount spent on loot boxes and the severity of problem gambling. The authors state that "the primary limitation of this study is its correlational nature", so it does not show which causes which.
Kind 3: real machines, played remotely
Google Play describes an online crane game as one where "the player maneuvers the claw from an app", controlling an actual claw machine "located in an offline gaming arcade." Google ran a pilot for these apps in Japan. Its real-money policy says the pilot ended on 11 July 2023 and that from 12 July 2023 online crane game apps "may be listed on Google Play globally subject to applicable law and certain requirements." Developers must submit a declaration form and accept terms before listing such an app.
The context matters. For other apps, Google Play's real-money policy lists "games that accept money in exchange for an opportunity to win a physical or monetary prize" as an example of a violation. Remote crane games are a specific, declared exception, not a general green light for paid prize games.
Apple's guidelines treat gaming and gambling as "one of the most regulated offerings on the App Store." Section 5.3.3 says apps "may not use in-app purchase to purchase credit or currency for use in conjunction with real money gaming of any kind." Section 5.3.4 says real-money gaming apps need licensing where they are used, must be geo-restricted to those places, and must be free on the App Store. Whether a given claw app counts as real-money gaming is a question for Apple and the developer, not one we can answer for any specific app.
Our explainer on how online claw machines work describes the video and control side of remote play.
Age rules
For licensed gambling apps, Google Play requires that the app "must prevent under-age users from using the app" and be rated AO (Adult Only) or the IARC equivalent. Claw games that are not gambling apps are rated like other games, so check the age rating in the listing. If a child uses your phone, turn on purchase approval in your phone's settings before installing any game that sells items.
Five checks before you spend money in a claw app
- Which kind is it? Look for a postal address request and shipped prizes (kind 3) or virtual items (kinds 1 and 2).
- What does one play cost in real money? Convert the credit pack price into a price per play.
- Are odds shown for random items? They should be, under both store rules.
- What does shipping cost? For physical prizes, add it to the cost of each win.
- Do credits expire? Apple's guideline 3.1.1 says credits bought by in-app purchase "may not expire." Credits bought elsewhere or given as bonuses may follow different terms.
The full list is in our checklist for online claw apps.
Sources
- Apple, App Store Review Guidelines, sections 3.1.1 and 5.3. developer.apple.com/app-store/review/guidelines
- Google Play Console Help, "Real-Money Gambling, Games, and Contests". support.google.com/googleplay/android-developer/answer/9877032
- Google Play Console Help, "Online Crane Games". support.google.com/googleplay/android-developer/answer/12002615
- Google Play Console Help, "Payments" policy. support.google.com/googleplay/android-developer/answer/9858738
- Zendle D., Cairns P., "Video game loot boxes are linked to problem gambling: Results of a large-scale survey", PLOS ONE 13(11): e0206767, 21 November 2018. journals.plos.org